You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Add production-quality qutrit state-vector and density-matrix simulators to PECOS, then use them as independent references for verifying leakage-aware noise models, including GeneralNoiseModel and its Selene plugin.
The initial physical basis is:
|0>, |1>, |L>
The implementation should remain device-neutral. A generic qudit core is preferable if it does not compromise a clear qutrit API or delay the initial leakage use case.
Motivation
PECOS currently has two complementary pieces, but no production qutrit simulator:
The Rust density-matrix simulator is qubit-specific. It represents an N-qubit density matrix using a 2N-qubit state vector and assumes a local dimension of two throughout its indexing, gate traits, measurement, and state-access APIs.
GeneralNoiseModel represents leakage efficiently as stochastic classical bookkeeping: leaked qubits are tracked separately, ordinary gates are suppressed, and seepage returns a qubit to the computational subspace.
The existing stochastic model is appropriate for scalable QEC studies, but an independent physical qutrit simulation would let us verify that its ensemble behavior is correct and explore coherent leakage effects that classical leakage bookkeeping cannot represent.
Proposed simulators
Qutrit state vector
Store 3^N complex amplitudes and support shot-based quantum trajectories.
Required capabilities:
arbitrary one- and two-site qutrit unitaries;
computational-subspace qubit gates embedded as U + |L><L|;
native coherent coupling between computational and leakage levels;
computational and full {0, 1, L} measurements;
reset and preparation;
sampled Kraus channels with outcome probability, application, and renormalization;
deterministic seeding;
state/probability inspection suitable for tests.
This should be the more scalable physical-leakage backend: O(3^N) state storage, with mixed channels represented through trajectories across shots.
Qutrit density matrix
Store an exact 3^N x 3^N density operator.
Required capabilities:
the same unitary, measurement, reset, and preparation semantics as the state-vector simulator;
exact Kraus-channel application;
reduced density matrices and outcome distributions;
density-operator inspection;
validation helpers for trace preservation, Hermiticity, and positive semidefiniteness.
This is expected to be a small-system reference backend because storage scales as O(9^N).
Architecture
Investigate a shared local-dimension abstraction rather than copying the current qubit StateVec and DensityMatrix implementations. Possible public shapes include:
The design should not force qutrit operations into qubit-only traits such as CliffordGateable. Prefer explicit local-unitary, channel, and generalized-measurement capabilities, with convenience methods for embedded qubit gates.
State indexing, target ordering, endianness, and measurement conventions must be documented and shared by both simulators.
Noise-model verification
Use the exact density-matrix backend and state-vector trajectory backend to independently verify PECOS noise behavior.
The verification matrix should include:
noiseless computational-subspace circuits;
single- and two-qubit Pauli channels;
preparation leakage;
one- and two-qubit emission models;
leakage followed by gate suppression;
seepage back into the computational subspace;
reset of leaked states;
normal and leakage-aware measurement;
asymmetric readout;
idle noise and coherent rotations where applicable;
combined channels on deep, parallel, and entangling circuits;
multiple error and simulator seeds.
For stochastic comparisons:
Compute the exact outcome distribution with the qutrit density matrix.
Confirm qutrit state-vector trajectory averages converge to it.
Confirm GeneralNoiseModel trajectories converge to the same distribution for the subset of qutrit channels represented by its current classical-leakage semantics.
Run the same comparisons through the Selene plugin boundary so serialization and operation translation are also covered.
The test suite should detect vacuous circuits by comparing against a noiseless or intentionally different distribution, following the conformance approach introduced in PR #545.
Suggested phases
Define generalized local-state, operation, measurement, and state-access semantics.
Implement and test the qutrit/qudit state-vector core.
Add sampled Kraus trajectories and leakage/seepage channels.
Implement and test the exact qutrit/qudit density-matrix core.
Cross-validate unitary evolution between the two backends.
Cross-validate trajectory averages against exact Kraus evolution.
Decide whether either simulator should be exposed through PECOS engine and Python APIs.
Document scaling limits and intended use cases.
Acceptance criteria
Both simulators agree exactly, within numerical tolerance, for pure unitary circuits.
State-vector trajectory statistics agree with exact density-matrix results for mixed channels within a documented statistical tolerance.
Density matrices remain normalized, Hermitian, and positive semidefinite within numerical tolerance.
The supported subset of GeneralNoiseModel agrees with the independent qutrit reference across preparation, one-site, two-site, leakage, seepage, reset, and measurement channels.
Verification covers both direct PECOS execution and the Selene plugin boundary.
Tests and APIs contain no hardware- or vendor-specific parameters, gates, or assumptions.
Scaling and unsupported coherent-leakage semantics are documented clearly.
Non-goals
Replacing the efficient classical leakage bookkeeping used by large QEC simulations.
Claiming that an exact qutrit density matrix is scalable to large codes.
Changing GeneralNoiseModel semantics as part of the initial simulator implementation.
Summary
Add production-quality qutrit state-vector and density-matrix simulators to PECOS, then use them as independent references for verifying leakage-aware noise models, including
GeneralNoiseModeland its Selene plugin.The initial physical basis is:
The implementation should remain device-neutral. A generic qudit core is preferable if it does not compromise a clear qutrit API or delay the initial leakage use case.
Motivation
PECOS currently has two complementary pieces, but no production qutrit simulator:
GeneralNoiseModelrepresents leakage efficiently as stochastic classical bookkeeping: leaked qubits are tracked separately, ordinary gates are suppressed, and seepage returns a qubit to the computational subspace.The existing stochastic model is appropriate for scalable QEC studies, but an independent physical qutrit simulation would let us verify that its ensemble behavior is correct and explore coherent leakage effects that classical leakage bookkeeping cannot represent.
Proposed simulators
Qutrit state vector
Store
3^Ncomplex amplitudes and support shot-based quantum trajectories.Required capabilities:
U + |L><L|;{0, 1, L}measurements;This should be the more scalable physical-leakage backend:
O(3^N)state storage, with mixed channels represented through trajectories across shots.Qutrit density matrix
Store an exact
3^N x 3^Ndensity operator.Required capabilities:
This is expected to be a small-system reference backend because storage scales as
O(9^N).Architecture
Investigate a shared local-dimension abstraction rather than copying the current qubit
StateVecandDensityMatriximplementations. Possible public shapes include:The design should not force qutrit operations into qubit-only traits such as
CliffordGateable. Prefer explicit local-unitary, channel, and generalized-measurement capabilities, with convenience methods for embedded qubit gates.State indexing, target ordering, endianness, and measurement conventions must be documented and shared by both simulators.
Noise-model verification
Use the exact density-matrix backend and state-vector trajectory backend to independently verify PECOS noise behavior.
The verification matrix should include:
For stochastic comparisons:
GeneralNoiseModeltrajectories converge to the same distribution for the subset of qutrit channels represented by its current classical-leakage semantics.The test suite should detect vacuous circuits by comparing against a noiseless or intentionally different distribution, following the conformance approach introduced in PR #545.
Suggested phases
GeneralNoiseModelconformance tests.Acceptance criteria
GeneralNoiseModelagrees with the independent qutrit reference across preparation, one-site, two-site, leakage, seepage, reset, and measurement channels.Non-goals
GeneralNoiseModelsemantics as part of the initial simulator implementation.Related
MeasureLeakedrepresentation limitations in symbolic measurement histories.